Debunking Nutrition Myths

Be honest — how many nutrition myths have you fallen for? If you've ever panicked about eating after 8 PM, spent money on a "detox" tea, or believed that carbs are your mortal enemy, you're not alone. A 2024 JAMA study found that nearly 70% of popular nutrition content on social media contains inaccurate or misleading claims. That's not just annoying — it's keeping you from actually reaching your health goals.

March is National Nutrition Month, and there's no better time to separate evidence-based nutrition from wellness BS. Let's go through five of the most persistent myths, look at what research actually tells us, and figure out what you should do instead.

Myth #1: Detox Teas Cleanse Your Body of Toxins

What people believe: Your body accumulates "toxins" from processed food, pollution, and stress, and you need special teas, juice cleanses, or supplements to flush them out. Influencers love to show off their flat-tummy teas with promises of a total body reset.

What research actually shows: Your body already has a phenomenal detoxification system — it's called your liver and kidneys. These organs work around the clock to filter your blood, break down waste products, and eliminate what your body doesn't need. No tea is going to do that job better than the organs that literally evolved for it.

Most "detox" teas work through one mechanism: they contain senna or other laxatives that cause water loss. That flat stomach you see? It's dehydration, not detoxification. And chronic use of laxative teas can actually damage your digestive system, disrupt your electrolyte balance, and create dependency.

What to do instead: Support your body's natural detox system by staying well-hydrated, eating plenty of fiber from fruits and vegetables, getting enough sleep, and limiting ultra-processed foods. Your liver will thank you — and you'll save a lot of money on overpriced tea bags.

Myth #2: Eating After 8 PM Causes Weight Gain

What people believe: Your metabolism shuts down at night, so any food you eat after a certain hour gets stored directly as fat. Some versions of this myth set the cutoff at 6 PM, others at 8 PM, and some say you should never eat after sunset.

What research actually shows: Your body doesn't have a clock that suddenly switches from "burn mode" to "store mode." Weight management comes down to your total caloric intake and expenditure over time — not the hour on the clock when you eat.

The real reason late-night eating gets a bad reputation? People who eat late at night tend to make poorer food choices. You're more likely to reach for chips, cookies, or ice cream at 10 PM than you are at noon. It's the what, not the when, that matters. Research published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition has consistently shown that meal timing alone does not determine whether your body stores or burns calories.

What to do instead: Focus on what you're eating and how much, not when. If you're genuinely hungry at 9 PM, eat something nourishing — a small portion of leftovers, some Greek yogurt with berries, or a handful of nuts. Ignoring real hunger to follow an arbitrary time rule just leads to overeating the next day.

Myth #3: You Must Eat Within 30 Minutes After a Workout

What people believe: There's a magical "anabolic window" immediately after exercise. If you don't slam a protein shake within 30 minutes of your last rep, your workout was basically wasted and your muscles will shrivel up.

What research actually shows: The post-workout nutrition window is much wider than supplement companies want you to think. Research from the International Society of Sports Nutrition shows that the real window for optimal muscle protein synthesis is approximately 3 to 6 hours around your workout — meaning your pre-workout meal counts too.

If you ate a balanced meal 2-3 hours before training, your body still has plenty of amino acids circulating to support recovery. The 30-minute panic is largely a marketing strategy to sell post-workout supplements. For most people who eat regular meals, there's no need to rush.

What to do instead: Aim to eat a balanced meal containing protein and carbohydrates within a few hours of your workout. Don't stress about the exact timing. If you train fasted first thing in the morning, then yes, eating sooner afterward is a good idea. Otherwise, just eat your next regular meal and you'll be fine.

Myth #4: Alkaline Water Changes Your Body's pH

What people believe: Modern diets make your body "too acidic," which causes disease, fatigue, and weight gain. Drinking alkaline water (pH 8-9+) or eating alkaline foods will shift your body's pH to a healthier level and prevent illness.

What research actually shows: Your body maintains its blood pH within an incredibly tight range of 7.35-7.45 — and it does this automatically through your lungs and kidneys, regardless of what you eat or drink. If your blood pH actually shifted significantly in either direction, you'd be in the emergency room, not feeling energized.

The moment that alkaline water hits your stomach, it meets hydrochloric acid with a pH of about 1.5-3.5. Your stomach literally neutralizes it. There is no credible research showing that alkaline water provides health benefits beyond basic hydration — which regular water does just as well, for a lot less money.

What to do instead: Just drink water. Tap water, filtered water, spring water — whatever you prefer and will actually drink consistently. Staying hydrated is genuinely important for your health. The pH of that water is not. Save your money and put it toward actual whole foods that make a real difference.

Myth #5: Carbs Are the Enemy

What people believe: Carbohydrates make you fat, spike your blood sugar, cause inflammation, and should be eliminated or drastically reduced. Low-carb and zero-carb diets are often presented as the ultimate solution for weight loss and health.

What research actually shows: Your brain runs primarily on glucose — it uses about 120 grams of glucose per day just to function. Carbohydrates are your body's preferred energy source, and completely cutting them out can lead to fatigue, brain fog, irritability, and poor exercise performance.

The real issue isn't carbs as a category — it's the quality of carbs you choose. There's a massive nutritional difference between a bowl of quinoa with roasted vegetables and a bag of gummy bears, even though both are "carbs." Whole grains, fruits, vegetables, and legumes provide fiber, vitamins, minerals, and sustained energy. Refined sugars and processed flour products? Not so much.

Large-scale research, including data from Blue Zone populations (the longest-lived people on Earth), consistently shows that diets rich in whole-food carbohydrates are associated with longevity and lower disease rates.

What to do instead: Stop fearing carbs and start choosing better ones. Fill your plate with whole grains like quinoa and brown rice, starchy vegetables like sweet potatoes, fruits, and legumes. These foods give you sustained energy, keep you full, and provide nutrients that your body needs to function at its best.

The Bottom Line

Nutrition doesn't have to be complicated. The wellness industry profits from making you feel confused and inadequate — because confused people buy more products. But the actual science is remarkably consistent and has been for decades: eat mostly whole foods, include plenty of fruits and vegetables, choose quality proteins and fats, stay hydrated, and stop stressing about arbitrary rules that have no research behind them.

You don't need a detox. You don't need to fear the clock or carbs. You need accurate information and the confidence to ignore the noise. That's what evidence-based nutrition looks like.

Found this helpful? Share it with someone who needs to hear it. Follow @merinanutrition for more evidence-based nutrition content.